Thermal comfort and energy related occupancy behavior in Dutch residential dwellings

  • Anastasios Ioannou

Abstract

Residential buildings account for a significant amount of the national energy consumption of all OECD countries and consequently the EU and the Netherlands. Therefore, the national targets for CO2 reduction should include provisions for a more energy efficient building stock for all EU member states. 

National and European level policies the past decades have improved the quality of the building stock by setting stricter standards on the external envelope of newly made buildings, the efficiency of the mechanical and heating components, the renovation practices and by establishing an energy labelling system. Energy related occupancy behavior is a significant part, and relatively unchartered, of buildings’ energy consumption. This thesis tried to contribute to the understanding of the role of the occupant related to the energy consumption of residential buildings by means of simulations and experimental data obtained by an extensive measurement campaign.

The first part of this thesis was based on dynamic building simulations in combination with a Monte Carlo statistical analysis, which tried to shed light to the most influential parameters, including occupancy related ones, that affect the energy consumption and comfort (a factor that is believed to be integral to the energy related behavior of people in buildings). The reference building that was used for the simulations was the TU Delft Concept House that was built for the purposes of the European project SusLab NWE. The concept house was simulated as an A energy label (very efficient) and F label (very inefficient) dwelling and with three different heating systems. 

The analysis revealed that if behavioral parameters are not taken into account, the most critical parameters affecting heating consumption are the window U value, window g value, and wall conductivity. When the uncertainty of these parameters increases, the impact of the wall conductivity on heating consumption increases considerably. The most important finding was that when behavioral parameters like thermostat use and ventilation flow rate are added to the analysis, they dwarf the importance of the building parameters in relation to the energy consumption. For the thermal comfort (the PMV index was used as the established model for measuring indoor thermal comfort) the most influential parameters were found to be metabolic activity and clothing, while the thermostat had a secondary impact.

The simulations were followed by an extensive measurement campaign where an in-situ, non-intrusive, wireless sensor system was installed in 32, social housing, residential dwellings in the area of Den Haag. This sensor system was transmitting quantitative data such as temperature, humidity, CO2 levels, and motion every five minutes for a period of six months (the heating period between November to April) and from every room of the 32 dwellings that participated in the campaign. Furthermore, subjective data were gathered during an initial inspection during the installation of the sensor system, concerning the building envelope, the heating and ventilation systems of the dwellings. More importantly though, subjective data were gathered related to the indoor comfort of the occupants with the use of an apparatus that was developed specifically for the SusLab project. This gimmick, named the comfort dial, allowed us to capture data such as the occupants’ comfort level in the PMV 7 point scale. In addition further comfort related data like the occupants’ clothing ensemble, actions related to thermal comfort, and their metabolic activity were captured with the use of a diary. The subjective data measurement session lasted for a week for each dwelling. These data were time coupled real time with the quantitative data that were gathered by the sensor system. 

The data analysis focused on the two available indoor thermal comfort models, Fanger’s PMV index and the adaptive model. Concerning the PMV model the analysis showed that while the neutral temperatures are well predicted by the PMV method, the cold and warm sensations are not. It appears that tenants reported (on a statistically significant way) comfortable sensations while the PMV method does not predict such comfort. This indicates a certain level of psychological adaptation to occupant’s expectations. Additionally it was found that although clothing and metabolic activities were similar among tenants of houses with different thermal quality, the neutral temperature was different. Specifically in houses with a good energy rating, the neutral temperature was higher than in houses with a poor rating.

Concerning the adaptive model, which was developed as the answer to the discrepancies of Fanger’s model related to naturally ventilated buildings (the majority of the residential sector), data analysis showed that while indoor temperatures are within the adaptive model’s comfort bandwidth, occupants often reported comfort sensations other than neutral. In addition, when indoor temperatures were below the comfort bandwidth, tenants often reported that they felt ‘neutral’. The adaptive model could overestimate as well as underestimate the occupant’s adaptive capacity towards thermal comfort. Despite the significant outdoors temperature variation, the indoor temperature of the dwellings, as well as the clothing of the tenants, were largely constant. Certain actions towards thermal comfort such as ‘turning the thermostat up’ were taking place while tenants were reporting thermal sensation ‘neutral’ or ‘a bit warm’. This indicates that either there is an indiscrimination among the various thermal sensation levels or alliesthesia, a new concept introduced by the creators of the adaptive model, plays an increased role. Most importantly there was an uncertainty on whether the neutral sensation means at the same time comfortable sensation while many actions are happening out of habit and not in order to improve one’s thermal comfort. A chi² analysis showed that only six actions were correlated to thermal sensation in thermally poorly efficient dwellings, and six in thermally efficient dwellings.

Finally, the abundance of data collected during the measurement campaign led the last piece of research of this thesis to data mining and pattern recognition analysis. Since the introduction of computers, the way research is performed has changed significantly. Huge amounts of data can be gathered and handled by evermore faster computers; the analysis of these data a couple of decades ago would take years. 

Sequential pattern mining reveals frequently occurring patterns from time-ordered input streams of data. A great deal of nature behaves in a periodic manner and these strong periodic elements of our environment have led people to adopt periodic behavior in many aspects of their lives such as the time they wake up in the morning, the daily working hours, the weekend days off, the weekly sports practice. These periodic interactions could extend in various aspects of our lives including the relationship of people with their home thermal environment. Repetitive behavioural actions in sensor rich environments, such as the dwellings of the measurement campaign, can be observed and categorized into patterns. These discoveries could form the basis of a model of tenant behaviour that could lead to a self-learning automation strategy or better occupancy data to be used for better predictions of building simulating software such as Energy+ or ESP-r and others. 

The analysis revealed various patterns of behaviour; indicatively 59% of the dwellings during the morning hours (7-9 a.m.) were increasing their indoor temperature from 20 oC< T< 22 oC to T> 22oC or that the tenants of 56% of the dwellings were finding the temperature 20 oC< T< 22 oC to be a bit cool and even for temperatures above 22 oC they were having a warm shower leading to the suspicion that a warm shower is a routine action not related to thermal comfort.

Such pattern recognition algorithms can be more effective in the era of mobile internet, which allows the capturing of huge amounts of data. Increased computational power can analyse these data and define useful patterns of behaviour that could be tailor made for each dwelling, for each room of a dwelling, even for each individual of a dwelling. The occupants could then have an overview of their most common behavioural patterns, see which ones are energy consuming, which ones are related to comfort and which are redundant, and therefore, could be discarded leading to energy savings. In any case the balance between indoor comfort and energy consumption will be the final factor that would lead the occupant to decide on a customised model of his indoor environment. 

The general conclusion of this thesis is that the effect of energy related occupancy behaviour on the energy consumption of dwellings should not be statistically defined for large groups of population. There are so many different types of people inhabiting so many different types of dwellings that embarking in such a task would be a considerable waste of time and resources.

The future in understanding the energy related occupancy behaviour, and therefore using it towards a more sustainable built environment, lies in the advances of sensor technology, big data gathering, and machine learning. Technology will enable us to move from big population models to tailor made solutions designed for each individual occupant.

 

References

CHAPTER 1
https://ec.europa.eu/energy/en/topics/energy-efficiency/buildings
Pérez-Lombard, Luis, José Ortiz, and Christine Pout. “A review on buildings’ energy consumption
information.” Energy and buildings 40.3 (2008): 394-398.
International Energy Agency, Key World Energy Statistics, 2016.
http://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/statistics-explained/index.php/File:Final_energy_consumption,_EU-28,_2014_(%25_of_total,_based_on_tonnes_of_oil_equivalent)_YB16.png
Energy Information Administration, International Energy Outlook 2016
Directive 2002/91/CE of the European Parliament and of the Council of 16, December 2002 on the energy performance of buildings, 2002.
Guerra Santin, O. “Actual energy consumption in dwellings: the effect of energy performance regulations and occupant behavior.” Sustainable Urban Areas 33 (2010).
Jeeninga, H., M. Uyterlimde, and J. Uitzinger. “Energy use of energy efficient residences.” Report ECN & IVAM (2001).
Lutzenhiser, Loren. “A question of control: alternative patterns of room air-conditioner use.” Energy and Buil-
dings 18.3 (1992): 193-200.
V.I. Soebarto, T.J. Williamson, Multi-criteria assessment of building performance: theory and implementation, Build. Environ. 36 (6) (2001) 681–690.
Yudelson, Greening Existing Buildings, McGraw-Hill New York, 2010.
C.M. Clevenger, J. Haymaker, The impact of the building occupant on energy modeling simulations, In: Joint
International Conference on Computing and Decision Making in Civil and Building Engineering, Montreal, Canada, Citeseer,2006, pp. 1–10.
Gommans, L. J. “Energy performances of energy efficient buildings.” TVVL magazine (2008): 18-24.
Nieman., “Eindrapportage woonkwaliteit binnenmilieu in nieuwbouwoning.” Report Wu060315aaA4.PK, VROM Inspectie Regio Oost, Arnhem (2007).
Hens, Hugo, Wout Parijs, and Mieke Deurinck. “Energy consumption for heating and rebound effects.” Energy and buildings 42.1 (2010): 105-110.
Haas, Reinhard, Hans Auer, and Peter Biermayr. “The impact of consumer behavior on residential energy
demand for space heating.” Energy and buildings 27.2 (1998): 195-205.
Nicol, Fergus, and Ken Parsons. “Special issue on thermal comfort standards.” Energy and Buildings 34.6 (2002): 529-532.
Fanger, P. O. “Thermal comfort. Analysis and applications in environmental engineering.” Thermal comfort. Analysis and applications in environmental engineering. (1970).
De Dear, Richard J., et al. “Developing an adaptive model of thermal comfort and preference/
discussion.” ASHRAE transactions 104 (1998): 145.
De Dear, Richard J., and Gail S. Brager. “Thermal comfort in naturally ventilated buildings: revisions to ASHRAE Standard 55.” Energy and buildings 34.6 (2002): 549-561.
Roaf, Sue, et al. “Twentieth century standards for thermal comfort: promoting high energy buildings.” Archi-
tectural Science Review 53.1 (2010): 65-77.
Yang, Liu, Haiyan Yan, and Joseph C. Lam. “Thermal comfort and building energy consumption implications–a review.” Applied Energy 115 (2014): 164-173.
Ioannou, A., and L. C. M. Itard. “Energy performance and comfort in residential buildings: Sensitivity for building parameters and occupancy.” Energy and Buildings 92 (2015): 216-233.
De Dear, Richard J. “A global database of thermal comfort field experiments.” ASHRAE transactions 104 (1998): 1141.
Humphreys, Michael A., and J. Fergus Nicol. “Outdoor temperature and indoor thermal comfort: Raising the
precision of the relationship for the 1998 ASHRAE database of field studies/Discussion.” Ashrae
Transactions 106 (2000): 485.
Arens, Edward, et al. “Are ‘class A’ temperature requirements realistic or desirable?.” Building and
Environment 45.1 (2010): 4-10.
Nicol, J. Fergus, and Michael A. Humphreys. “Adaptive thermal comfort and sustainable thermal standards for buildings.” Energy and buildings 34.6 (2002): 563-572.
Santamouris, M., et al. “Freezing the poor—Indoor environmental quality in low and very low income
households during the winter period in Athens.” Energy and Buildings 70 (2014): 61-70.
Jan Gilbertson, et al., Psychosocial routes from housing investment to health: evidence from England’s home energy efficiency scheme, Energy Policy 49(2012) 122–133.
Shipworth Michelle, et al., Central heating thermostat settings and timing: building demographics, Build. Res. Inf. 38.1 (2010) 50–69.
Oreszczyn Tadj, et al., Determinants of winter indoor temperatures in low income households in England,
Energy Build. 38.3 (2006) 245–252.
A.J. Summerfield, et al., Milton Keynes Energy Park revisited: changes in internal temperatures and energy usage, Energy Build. 39.7 (2007) 783–791.
Yohanis, Yigzaw Goshu, and Jayanta Deb Mondol Annual variations of temperature in a sample of UK dwellings, Appl. Energy 87.2 (2010) 681–690.
Emma J. Hutchinson, et al., Can we improve the identification of cold homes for targeted home energy-efficiency improvements? Appl. Energy 83.11(2006) 1198–1209.
Barbhuiya, Saadia, and Salim Barbhuiya Thermal comfort and energy consumption in a UK educational building, Build. Environ. 68 (2013) 1–11.
Sung H. Hong, et al., A field study of thermal comfort in low-income dwellings in England before and after energy efficient refurbishment, Build. Environ.(2009) 1223–1236.
M. Kavgic, et al., Characteristics of indoor temperatures over winter for Belgrade urban dwellings: indications of thermal comfort and space heating energy demand, Energy Build. 47 (2012) 506–514.
Singh Manoj Kumar, Sadhan Mahapatra, S.K. Atreya, Thermal performance study and evaluation of comfort temperatures in vernacular buildings of North-East India, Build. Environ. 45.2 (2010) 320–329.
Marc. Delghust, Improving the predictive power of simplified residential space heating demand models: a field data and model driven study, Diss. Ghent Univ. (2015).
John D. Healy, J. Peter, Clinch Fuel poverty, thermal comfort and occupancy: results of a national household-
survey in Ireland, Appl. Energy 73.3 (2002)329–343.
Critchley Roger, et al., Living in cold homes after heating improvements: evidence from Warm-Front, England’s Home Energy Efficiency Scheme, Appl. Energ. 84.2 (2007) 147–158.
Majcen, Dasa. “Predicting energy consumption and savings in the housing stock: A performance gap analysis in the Netherlands.” (2016).
Dell’Isola, Alphonse, and Stephen J. Kirk. Life cycle costing for facilities. Vol. 51. RSMeans, 2003.
Azar, Elie, and Carol C. Menassa. “Agent-based modeling of occupants and their impact on energy use in
commercial buildings.” Journal of Computing in Civil Engineering 26.4 (2011): 506-518.
Peschiera, Gabriel, John E. Taylor, and Jeffrey A. Siegel. “Response–relapse patterns of building occupant electricity consumption following exposure to personal, contextualized and occupant peer network utilization data.” Energy and Buildings 42.8 (2010): 1329-1336.
Rasooli, Arash, Laure Itard, and Carlos Infante Ferreira. “A response factor-based method for the rapid in-situ determination of wall’s thermal resistance in existing buildings.” Energy and Buildings 119 (2016): 51-61.
Kalogirou, Soteris A. “Applications of artificial neural-networks for energy systems.” Applied energy 67.1 (2000): 17-35.
Lam, Joseph C., Kevin KW Wan, and Liu Yang. “Sensitivity analysis and energy conservation measures
implications.” Energy Conversion and Management 49.11 (2008): 3170-3177.
Lam, Joseph C., and Sam CM Hui. “Sensitivity analysis of energy performance of office buildings.” Building and Environment 31.1 (1996): 27-39.
Wang, Jiangjiang, et al. “Sensitivity analysis of optimal model on building cooling heating and power
system.” Applied energy 88.12 (2011): 5143-5152.
Saporito, A., et al. “Multi-parameter building thermal analysis using the lattice method for global
optimisation.” Energy and buildings 33.3 (2001): 267-274.
http://suslab.eu
http://www.monicair.nl
http://installaties2020.weebly.com
Lomas, Kevin J., and Herbert Eppel. “Sensitivity analysis techniques for building thermal simulation
programs.” Energy and buildings 19.1 (1992): 21-44.
Peeters, Leen, et al. “Thermal comfort in residential buildings: Comfort values and scales for building energy simulation.” Applied Energy 86.5 (2009): 772-780.
Van der Linden, A. C., et al. “Adaptive temperature limits: A new guideline in The Netherlands: A new approach for the assessment of building performance with respect to thermal indoor climate.” Energy and buildings 38.1 (2006): 8-17.
Filippidou, Faidra, Nico Nieboer, and Henk Visscher. “Energy efficiency measures implemented in the Dutch non-profit housing sector.” Energy and Buildings 132 (2016): 107-116.
van den Brom, Paula, Arjen Meijer, and Henk Visscher. “Performance gaps in energy consumption: household groups and building characteristics.” Building Research & Information (2017): 1-17.
Majcen, D., L. C. M. Itard, and H. Visscher. “Theoretical vs. actual energy consumption of labelled dwellings in the Netherlands: Discrepancies and policy implications.” Energy policy 54 (2013): 125-136.
Majcen, Daša, Laure Itard, and Henk Visscher. “Statistical model of the heating prediction gap in Dutch
dwellings: Relative importance of building, household and behavioral characteristics.” Energy and Buildings 105 (2015): 43-59.
Majcen, Daša, Laure Itard, and Henk Visscher. “Actual heating energy savings in thermally renovated Dutch dwellings.” Energy Policy 97 (2016): 82-92.
Guerra-Santin, Olivia, and Laure Itard. “Occupants’ behavior: determinants and effects on residential heating consumption.” Building Research & Information 38.3 (2010): 318-338.
ISSO, 2009. ISSO 82.3 Publication Energy Performance Certificate—Formula Structure (Publicatie 82.3
Handleiding EPA-W (Formulestructuur’), Senternovem, October 2009.
Aedes (2014). Rapportage energiebesparingsmonitor SHAERE 2013. www.aedes.nl/binaries/downloads/
energie-en-duurzaamheid/rapportage-shaere-2013.pdf
Poortinga, Wouter, Linda Steg, and Charles Vlek. “Values, environmental concern, and environmental behavior: A study into household energy use.” Environment and behavior 36.1 (2004): 70-93.
Gram-Hanssen, Kirsten, Casper Kofod, and K. Nærvig Petersen. “Different everyday lives: different patterns of electricity use.” 2004 ACEEE Summer study on energy efficiency in buildings. 2004.
Brager, Gail S., and Richard J. De Dear. “Thermal adaptation in the built environment: a literature review.” Energy and buildings 27.1 (1998): 83-96.
J. Jensen, Measuring consumption in households: interpretations and strategies, Ecological Economics 68 (1–2) (2008) 353–361.
De Dear, Richard. “Revisiting an old hypothesis of human thermal perception: alliesthesia.” Building Research & Information 39.2 (2011): 108-117.

CHAPTER 2
V.I. Soebarto, T.J. Williamson, Multi-criteria assessment of building performance: theory and implementation, Building and Environment, 36 (6) (2001) 681-690.
A.J. Dell’Isola, S.J. Kirk, Life cycle costing for facilities: economic analysis for owners and professionals in planning, programming, and real estate development: designing, specifying, and construction, maintenance, operations, and procurement, Robert s Means Co, 2003.
D. Majcen, L.C.M. Itard, H. Visscher, Theoretical vs. actual energy consumption of labelled dwellings in the
Netherlands: Discrepancies and policy implications, Energy Policy, 54 (2013) 125-136.
D. Majcen, L. Itard, H. Visscher, Actual and theoretical gas consumption in Dutch dwellings: What causes the differences?, Energy Policy, 61 (2013) 460-471.
O. Guerra-Santin, L. Itard, The effect of energy performance regulations on energy consumption, Energy
Efficiency, 5 (3) (2012) 269-282.
J.Yudelson, Greening existing buildings, McGraw-Hill New York, 2010.
C.M. Clevenger, J. Haymaker, The impact of the building occupant on energy modeling simulations, in: Joint
International Conference on Computing and Decision Making in Civil and Building Engineering, Montreal, Canada, Citeseer, 2006, pp. 1-10.
E. Azar, C.C. Menassa, Agent-Based Modeling of Occupants and Their Impact on Energy Use in Commercial Buildings, Journal of Computing in Civil Engineering, 26 (4) (2012) 506-518.
G. Peschiera, J.E. Taylor, J.A. Siegel, Response–relapse patterns of building occupant electricity consumption
following exposure to personal, contextualized and occupant peer network utilization data, Energy and Buildings, 42 (8) (2010) 1329-1336.
J.C. Lam, K.K. Wan, L. Yang, Sensitivity analysis and energy conservation measures implications, Energy
Conversion and Management, 49 (11) (2008) 3170-3177.
J.C. Lam, S. Hui, Sensitivity analysis of energy performance of office buildings, Building and Environment, 31 (1) (1996) 27-39.
A. Rabl, A. Rialhe, Energy signature models for commercial buildings: test with measured data and inter-
pretation, Energy and Buildings, 19 (2) (1992) 143-154.
K.J. Lomas, H. Eppel, Sensitivity analysis techniques for building thermal simulation programs, Energy and buildings, 19 (1) (1992) 21-44.
C. Turner, M. Frankel, U.G.B. Council, Energy performance of LEED for new construction buildings, New
Buildings Institute Vancouver, WA, 2008.
J. Wang, Z.J. Zhai, Y. Jing, X. Zhang, C. Zhang, Sensitivity analysis of optimal model on building cooling heating and power system, Applied Energy, 88 (12) (2011) 5143-5152.
W. Lee, H. Chen, Benchmarking Hong Kong and China energy codes for residential buildings, Energy and
Buildings, 40 (9) (2008) 1628-1636.
A. Saporito, A. Day, T. Karayiannis, F. Parand, Multi-parameter building thermal analysis using the lattice
method for global optimisation, Energy and buildings, 33 (3) (2001) 267-274.
C.J. Hopfe, Uncertainty and sensitivity analysis in building performance simulation for decision support and design optimization, PhD diss., Eindhoven University, (2009).
E. ISO, 7730. 2005. Ergonomics of the thermal environment. Analytical determination and interpretation of thermal comfort using calculation of the PMV and PPD indices and local thermal comfort criteria, International Standardisation Organisation, Geneva, 147 (2005).
G.S. Brager, R.J. de Dear, Thermal adaptation in the built environment: a literature review, Energy and buildings, 27 (1) (1998) 83-96.
M.A. Humphreys, M. Hancock, Do people like to feel ‘neutral’?: Exploring the variation of the desired thermal sensation on the ASHRAE scale, Energy and Buildings, 39 (7) (2007) 867-874.
E. Shove, Social, architectural and environmental convergence, Environmental Diversity in Architecture, (2004) 19-30.
M.J. Holmes, J.N. Hacker, Climate change, thermal comfort and energy: Meeting the design challenges of the 21st century, Energy and Buildings, 39 (7) (2007) 802-814.
M. Jokl, K. Kabele, The substitution of comfort pmv values by a new experimental operative temperature, Czech Technical University, Clima WellBeing Indoors, (2007).
D. Fiala, K. Lomas, The dynamic effect of adaptive human responses in the sensation of thermal comfort, in: Proceedings Windsor Conference, 2001, pp. 147-157.
N. Baker, M. Standeven, Thermal comfort for free-running buildings, Energy and Buildings, 23 (3) (1996) 175-182.
A. ASHRAE, Standard 55-2004, Thermal Environmental Conditions for Human Occupancy, Atlanta: American Society of Heating, Refrigerating, and Air-conditioning Engineers, Inc., USA, (2004).
P. Heiselberg, H. Brohus, A. Hesselholt, H. Rasmussen, E. Seinre, S. Thomas, Application of sensitivity analysis in design of sustainable buildings, Renewable Energy, 34 (9) (2009) 2030-2036.
A. Saltelli, S. Tarantola, F. Campolongo, Sensitivity anaysis as an ingredient of modeling, Statistical Science, 15 (4) (2000) 377-395.
A. Saltelli, K. Chan, E.M. Scott, Sensitivity analysis, Wiley New York, 2000.
D. Hamby, A review of techniques for parameter sensitivity analysis of environmental models, Environmental Monitoring and Assessment, 32 (2) (1994) 135-154.
M.D. Morris, Factorial sampling plans for preliminary computational experiments, Technometrics, 33 (2) (1991) 161-174.
R. Judkoff, D. Wortman, B. O’doherty, J. Burch, A methodology for validating building energy analysis
simulations, National Renewable Energy Laboratory Golden, CO, 2008.
B. Hunn, W. Turk, W. Wray, Validation of passive-solar analysis/design tools using Class A performance-
evaluation data, in, Los Alamos National Lab., NM (USA), 1982.
I.A. Macdonald, Comparison of sampling techniques on the performance of Monte-Carlo based sensitivity analysis, in: Eleventh International IBPSA Conference, 2009, pp. 992-999.
J.C. Helton, F.J. Davis, Latin hypercube sampling and the propagation of uncertainty in analyses of complex systems, Reliability Engineering & System Safety, 81 (1) (2003) 23-69.
I.A. Macdonald, Quantifying the effects of uncertainty in building simulation, University of Strathclyde, 2002.
M.S. de Wit, Uncertainty in predictions of thermal comfort in buildings, Delft University, The, (2001).
IBM Corp. Released 2011. IBM SPSS Statistics for Windows, Version 20.0. Armonk, NY: IBM Corp.
R.L. Iman, W.J. Conover, The use of the rank transform in regression, Technometrics, 21 (4) (1979) 499-509.
EnergyPlus Input Output Reference: The encyclopaedic reference to EnergyPlus Input and Output. October 8, 2012. .
EnergyPlus Engineering Reference: The Reference to EnergyPlus Calculations, October 8 2012.
Y. Zhang, I. Korolija, Performing complex parametric simulations with jEPlus, (2010).
Y. Zhang, ‘Parallel’EnergyPlus and the development of a parametric analysis tool, in: IBPSA Conference, 2009, pp. 1382-1388.
ISSO 82.3 Publication Energy Performance Certificate—Formula Structure (Publicatie 82.3 Handleiding EPA-W (Formulestructuur’), Senternovem, October 2009.
Directive 2010/31/EU of the European Parliament and of the Council of the 19 May 2010 on the Energy Performance of Buildings.
O. Guerra-Santin, L. Itard, Occupants’ behavior: determinants and effects on residential heating consumption, Building Research & Information, 38 (3) (2010) 318-338.
Nederlandse Norm NEN 1087, 2001. Ventilatie van Gebouwen - Bepalingsmethoden voor nieuwbouw. Vervangt NEN 1087:1997, ICS 91.140.30, December 2001.
P.C.M. Zegers, Prestaties van thermisch-comfort installaties in woningbouw in Nederland, Civil Engineering and Geosciences-- Department of Design and Construction, TU Delft, 2011.
O. Guerra Santin, Actual energy consumption in dwellings: The effect of energy performance regulations and occupant behavior, Faculty of Architecture--Department OTB, TU Delft, 2010-10-19.
F. ASHRAE, Fundamentals Handbook, IP Edition, (2009).
P.O. Fanger, Thermal comfort. Analysis and applications in environmental engineering, Thermal comfort.
Analysis and applications in environmental engineering., (1970).
S. Sattari, B. Farhanieh, A parametric study on radiant floor heating system performance, Renewable Energy, 31 (10) (2006) 1617-1626.
T. Chen, Application of adaptive predictive control to a floor heating system with a large thermal lag, Energy and Buildings, 34 (1) (2002) 45-51.
http://www.suslab.eu/
http://www.monicair.nl/

CHAPTER 3
Balaras, C.A., Gaglia, A.G., Georgopoulou, E., Mirasgedis, S., Sarafidis, Y. and Lalas, D.P., 2007. European
residential buildings and empirical assessment of the Hellenic building stock, energy consumption, emissions and potential energy savings. Building and environment, 42(3), pp.1298-1314.
Majcen, D., L. C. M. Itard, and H. Visscher. “Theoretical vs. actual energy consumption of labelled dwellings in the Netherlands: Discrepancies and policy implications.” Energy policy 54 (2013): 125-136.
Soebarto, V.I. and Williamson, T.J., 2001. Multi-criteria assessment of building performance: theory and
implementation. Building and Environment,36(6), pp.681-690.
Yudelson, J., 2010. Greening existing buildings. New York: McGraw-Hill.
Clevenger, C.M. and Haymaker, J., 2006, June. The impact of the building occupant on energy modelling
simulations. In Joint International Conference on Computing and Decision Making in Civil and Building
Engineering, Montreal, Canada (pp. 1-10).
Azar, E. and Menassa, C.C., 2011. Agent-based modelling of occupants and their impact on energy use in
commercial buildings. Journal of Computing in Civil Engineering, 26(4), pp.506-518.
Peschiera, G., Taylor, J.E. and Siegel, J.A., 2010. Response–relapse patterns of building occupant electricity consumption following exposure to personal, contextualized and occupant peer network utilization data. Energy and Buildings, 42(8), pp.1329-1336.
ISO E, 7730, 2005. Ergonomics of the Thermal Environment. Analytical Determination and Interpretation of Thermal Comfort using Calculation of the PMV and PPD Indices and Local Thermal Comfort Criteria.
International Standardisation Organisation, Geneva (2005), p. 147
Becker, R. and Paciuk, M., 2009. Thermal comfort in residential buildings–failure to predict by standard
model. Building and Environment, 44(5), pp.948-960.
De Dear, R.J., Leow, K.G. and Foo, S.C., 1991. Thermal comfort in the humid tropics: Field experiments in air conditioned and naturally ventilated buildings in Singapore. International Journal of Biometeorology, 34(4), pp.259-265.
Humphreys, M.A., 1994, June. Field studies and climate chamber experiments in thermal comfort research. In Thermal comfort: past, present and future. Proceedings of a conference held at the Building Research
Establishment, Garston (pp. 9-10).
Oseland, N.A., 1994. A comparison of the predicted and reported thermal sensation vote in homes during winter and summer. Energy and Buildings, 21(1), pp.45-54.
Bouden, C. and Ghrab, N., 2005. An adaptive thermal comfort model for the Tunisian context: a field study results. Energy and Buildings, 37(9), pp.952-963.
Fanger, P.O. and Toftum, J., 2002. Extension of the PMV model to non-air-conditioned buildings in warm climates. Energy and buildings, 34(6), pp.533-536.
Humphreys, M.A. and Nicol, J.F., 2002. The validity of ISO-PMV for predicting comfort votes in every-day
thermal environments. Energy and buildings, 34(6), pp.667-684.
Peeters, L., De Dear, R., Hensen, J. and D’haeseleer, W., 2009. Thermal comfort in residential buildings: Comfort values and scales for building energy simulation. Applied Energy, 86(5), pp.772-780.
Yoshino, Hiroshi, et al. “Indoor thermal environment and energy saving for urban residential buildings in China.” Energy and buildings 38.11 (2006): 1308-1319.
Ioannou, A., and L. C. M. Itard. “Energy performance and comfort in residential buildings: Sensitivity for building parameters and occupancy.” Energy and Buildings 92 (2015): 216-233.
Magalhães, Sara MC, Vítor MS Leal, and Isabel M. Horta. “Predicting and characterizing indoor temperatures in residential buildings: Results from a monitoring campaign in Northern Portugal.” Energy and Buildings 119 (2016): 293-308.
Santamouris, M., et al. “Freezing the poor—Indoor environmental quality in low and very low income
households during the winter period in Athens.”Energy and Buildings 70 (2014): 61-70.
Gilbertson, Jan, et al. “Psychosocial routes from housing investment to health: Evidence from England’s home energy efficiency scheme.” Energy Policy 49 (2012): 122-133.
Shipworth, Michelle, et al. “Central heating thermostat settings and timing: building demographics.” Building Research & Information 38.1 (2010): 50-69.
Oreszczyn, Tadj, et al. “Determinants of winter indoor temperatures in low income households in England.” 
Energy and Buildings 38.3 (2006): 245-252.
Summerfield, A. J., et al. “Milton Keynes Energy Park revisited: Changes in internal temperatures and energy usage.” Energy and Buildings 39.7 (2007): 783-791.
Yohanis, Yigzaw Goshu, and Jayanta Deb Mondol. “Annual variations of temperature in a sample of UK
dwellings.” Applied Energy 87.2 (2010): 681-690.
Hutchinson, Emma J., et al. “Can we improve the identification of cold homes for targeted home energy-
efficiency improvements?.” Applied Energy83.11 (2006): 1198-1209.
Barbhuiya, Saadia, and Salim Barbhuiya. “Thermal comfort and energy consumption in a UK educational
building.” Building and Environment 68 (2013): 1-11.
Hong, Sung H., et al. “A field study of thermal comfort in low-income dwellings in England before and after energy efficient refurbishment.”Building and Environment 44.6 (2009): 1228-1236.
Kavgic, M., et al. “Characteristics of indoor temperatures over winter for Belgrade urban dwellings: indications of thermal comfort and space heating energy demand.” Energy and Buildings 47 (2012): 506-514.
Singh, Manoj Kumar, Sadhan Mahapatra, and S. K. Atreya. “Thermal performance study and evaluation of comfort temperatures in vernacular buildings of North-East India.” Building and environment 45.2 (2010): 320-329.
Delghust, Marc. Improving the predictive power of simplified residential space heating demand models: a field data and model driven study. Diss. Ghent University, 2015.
Healy, John D., and J. Peter Clinch. “Fuel poverty, thermal comfort and occupancy: results of a national
household-survey in Ireland.” Applied Energy 73.3 (2002): 329-343.
Critchley, Roger, et al. “Living in cold homes after heating improvements: evidence from Warm-Front, England’s Home Energy Efficiency Scheme.”Applied Energy 84.2 (2007): 147-158.
http://monicair.nl/
www.SusLabNWE.eu
http://installaties2020.weebly.com/
Guerra-Santin, Olivia, and Laure Itard. “Occupants’ behavior: determinants and effects on residential heating consumption.” Building Research & Information 38.3 (2010): 318-338.
Majcen D., Itard L., Visscher H. 2015, Statistical model of the heating prediction gap in Dutch dwell-ings:
Relative importance of building, household and behavioral characteristics, Energy and Buildings 105 (2015), 43-59.
Majcen, Daša, Laure Itard, and Henk Visscher. “Actual heating energy savings in thermally renovated Dutch dwellings.” Energy Policy 97 (2016): 82-92.
ISSO, 2009. ISSO 82.3 Publication Energy Performance Certificate—Formula Structure (Publicatie 82.3
Handleiding EPA-W (Formulestructuur’), Senternovem, October 2009.
Aedes (2014). Rapportage energiebesparingsmonitor SHAERE 2013. www.aedes.nl/binaries/downloads/
energie-en-duurzaamheid/rapportage-shaere-2013.pdf
Fanger, P. O. “Thermal comfort. Analysis and applications in environmental engineering.” Thermal comfort. Analysis and applications in environmental engineering. (1970).
Handbook, ASHRAE Fundamentals. “American society of heating, refrigerating and air-conditioning
engineers.” Inc.: Atlanta, GA, USA (2009).
Zhang, Hui, et al. “Thermal sensation and comfort in transient non-uniform thermal environments.” European journal of applied physiology 92.6 (2004): 728-733.
Du, Xiuyuan, et al. “The response of human thermal sensation and its prediction to temperature step-change (Cool-Neutral-Cool).” PloS one 9.8 (2014): e104320.
Khan, Muhammad Hammad, and William Pao. “Thermal Comfort Analysis of PMV Model Prediction in Air
Conditioned and Naturally Ventilated Buildings.”Energy Procedia 75 (2015): 1373-1379.
Beizaee, Arash, and Steven K. Firth. “A comparison of calculated and subjective thermal comfort sensation in home and office environment.” (2011).
Halawa, E., and J. Van Hoof. “The adaptive approach to thermal comfort: A critical overview.” Energy and
Buildings 51 (2012): 101-110.
EnergyPlus Input Output Reference: The encyclopaedic reference to EnergyPlus Input and Output. October 8, 2012.
Heidari, Shahin, and Steve Sharples. “A comparative analysis of short-term and long-term thermal comfort surveys in Iran.” Energy and Buildings 34.6 (2002): 607-614.
Khedari, Joseph, Boonlert Boonsri, and Jongjit Hirunlabh. “Ventilation impact of a solar chimney on indoor
temperature fluctuation and air change in a school building.” Energy and buildings 32.1 (2000): 89-93.
RP, ASHRAE. “Developing an Adaptive Model of Thermal Comfort and Preference.” (1997).
Glaser, Eric Michael. The physiological basis of habituation. Oxford UP, 1966.
Frisancho, A. Roberto. Human adaptation and accommodation. University of Michigan Press, 1993.
NEN-EN 50131-5-3:2005 en - Alarm systems - Intrusion systems - Part 5-3: Requirements for inter-
connections equipment using radio frequency techniques
ISO, EN. “7726.” Ergonomics of the thermal environment-Instruments for measuring physical quantities (ISO 7726: 1998) (1998).
Majcen, Daša, Laure Itard, and Henk Visscher. “Statistical model of the heating prediction gap in Dutch
dwellings: Relative importance of building, household and behavioral characteristics.” Energy and Buildings 105 (2015): 43-59.

CHAPTER 4
Ioannou, Anastasios, and Laure Itard. “In-situ and real time measurements of thermal comfort and its
determinants in thirty residential dwellings in the Netherlands.” Energy and Buildings 139 (2017): 487-505.
De Dear, Richard J., et al. “Developing an adaptive model of thermal comfort and preference/
Discussion.” ASHRAE transactions 104 (1998): 145.
Nicol, J. Fergus, and Michael A. Humphreys. “Adaptive thermal comfort and sustainable thermal standards for buildings.” Energy and buildings 34.6 (2002): 563-572.
Karyono, Tri Harso. “Report on thermal comfort and building energy studies in Jakarta—Indonesia.” Building and environment 35.1 (2000): 77-90.
Feriadi, Henry, and Nyuk Hien Wong. “Thermal comfort for naturally ventilated houses in Indonesia.” Energy and Buildings 36.7 (2004): 614-626.
Wong, N. H., et al. “Thermal comfort evaluation of naturally ventilated public housing in Singapore.” Building and Environment 37.12 (2002): 1267-1277.
van der Linden, Kees, et al. “Thermal indoor climate building performance characterized by human comfort response.” Energy and Buildings 34.7 (2002): 737-744.
Fato, Ida, Francesco Martellotta, and Cecilia Chiancarella. “Thermal comfort in the climatic conditions of Southern Italy.” TRANSACTIONS-AMERICAN SOCIETY OF HEATING REFRIGERATING AND AIR CONDITIONING ENGINEERS 110.2 (2004): 578-593.
Standard, A. S. H. R. A. E. “Standard 55-2010.” Thermal environmental conditions for human occupancy (2010).
Cen, E. N. “15251, Indoor environmental input parameters for design and assessment of energy performance of buildings addressing indoor air quality, thermal environment, lighting and acoustics.” European Committee for Standardization, Brussels, Belgium (2007).
Van der Linden, A. C., et al. “Adaptive temperature limits: A new guideline in The Netherlands: A new approach for the assessment of building performance with respect to thermal indoor climate.” Energy and buildings 38.1 (2006): 8-17.
van Hoof, Joost, and Jan LM Hensen. “Quantifying the relevance of adaptive thermal comfort models in
moderate thermal climate zones.” Building and Environment 42.1 (2007): 156-170.
Baker, Nick, and Koen Steemers. Energy and environment in architecture: a technical design guide. Taylor & Francis, 2003.
De Dear, Richard. “Thermal comfort in practice.” Indoor air 14.s7 (2004): 32-39.
Fanger, P. O. “Thermal comfort. Analysis and applications in environmental engineering.” Thermal comfort. Analysis and applications in environmental engineering. (1970).
Halawa, E., and J. Van Hoof. “The adaptive approach to thermal comfort: A critical overview.” Energy and
Buildings 51 (2012): 101-110.
Dear, R. de, Gail Brager, and Donna Cooper. “Developing an adaptive model of thermal comfort and
preference-Final Report (ASHRAE RP-884).” Atlanta, GA: ASHRAE (1997).
Fountain, Marc, Gail Brager, and Richard de Dear. “Expectations of indoor climate control.” Energy and
Buildings 24.3 (1996): 179-182.
Morgan, Craig, and Richard de Dear. “Weather, clothing and thermal adaptation to indoor climate.” Climate Research 24.3 (2003): 267-284.
McIntyre, D. A. “Design requirements for a comfortable environment.” Studies in environmental science 10 (1981): 195-220.
de Dear, Richard. “Adaptive comfort applications in Australia and impacts on building energy
consumption.” Proceedings of the 6th International Conference On Indoor Air Quality, Ventilation and Energy Conservation in Buildings (IAQVEC 2007), Sendai, Japan. 2007.
De Dear, Richard. “Revisiting an old hypothesis of human thermal perception: alliesthesia.” Building Research & Information 39.2 (2011): 108-117.
http://www.monicair.nl
http://suslab.eu
http://installaties2020.weebly.com
Peeters, Leen, et al. “Thermal comfort in residential buildings: Comfort values and scales for building energy simulation.” Applied Energy 86.5 (2009): 772-780.
Oseland, Nigel A. “Predicted and reported thermal sensation in climate chambers, offices and homes.” Energy and Buildings 23.2 (1995): 105-115.
Niu, Jianlei, and John Burnett. “Integrating radiant/operative temperature controls into building energy
simulations.” ASHRAE Transactions 104 (1998): 210.
ISSO, 2009. ISSO 82.3 Publication Energy Performance Certificate—Formula Structure (Publicatie 82.3
Handleiding EPA-W (Formulestructuur’), Senternovem, October 2009.
http://sydney.edu.au/architecture/staff/homepage/richard_de_dear/ashrae_rp-884.shtml
Ioannou, A., and L. C. M. Itard. “Energy performance and comfort in residential buildings: Sensitivity for building parameters and occupancy.” Energy and Buildings 92 (2015): 216-233.

CHAPTER 5
Heierman, Ed, M. Youngblood, and Diane J. Cook. “Mining temporal sequences to discover interesting
patterns.” KDD Workshop on mining temporal and sequential data. 2004.
Page, Jessen, et al. “A generalized stochastic model for the simulation of occupant presence.” Energy and
buildings 40.2 (2008): 83-98.
Dong, Bing, and Burton Andrews. “Sensor-based occupancy behavioral pattern recognition for energy and
comfort management in intelligent buildings.” Proceedings of building simulation. 2009.
Fritsch, R., et al. “A stochastic model of user behavior regarding ventilation.” Building and Environment 25.2 (1990): 173-181.
Degelman, Larry O. “A model for simulation of day lighting and occupancy sensors as an energy control strategy for office buildings.” Proceedings of building simulation. Vol. 99. 1999.
Reinhart, Christoph F. “Lightswitch-2002: a model for manual and automated control of electric lighting and blinds.” Solar Energy 77.1 (2004): 15-28.
Wang, Danni, Clifford C. Federspiel, and Francis Rubinstein. “Modeling occupancy in single person offices.” 
Energy and buildings 37.2 (2005): 121-126.
Mahdavi, Ardeshir, et al. “User interactions with environmental control systems in buildings.” Proceedings PLEA. 2006.
Lam, Khee Poh, et al. “Occupancy detection through an extensive environmental sensor network in an open-plan office building.” IBPSA Building Simulation 145 (2009): 1452-1459.
Cook, Diane, and Sajal Kumar Das. Smart environments: Technology, protocols and applications. Vol. 43. John Wiley & Sons, 2004.
http://monicair.nl/.
www.SusLabNWE.eu.
http://installaties2020.weebly.com/.
Ioannou, Anastasios, and Laure Itard. “In-situ and real time measurements of thermal comfort and its
determinants in thirty residential dwellings in the Netherlands.” Energy and Buildings 139 (2017): 487-505.
In-situ real time measurements of thermal comfort and comparison with the adaptive comfort theory in Dutch residential dwellings.
Youngblood, G. Michael, and Diane J. Cook. “Data mining for hierarchical model creation.” IEEE Transactions on Systems, Man, and Cybernetics, Part C (Applications and Reviews) 37.4 (2007): 561-572.
Gupta, Manish, and Jiawei Han. “Applications of pattern discovery using sequential data mining.” Data Mining: Concepts, Methodologies, Tools, and Applications. IGI Global, 2013. 947-969.
Agrawal, Rakesh, and Ramakrishnan Srikant. “Mining sequential patterns.” Data Engineering, 1995. Proceedings of the Eleventh International Conference on. IEEE, 1995.
H. Mannila, H. Toivonen, and A. Verkamo. Discovering frequent episodes in sequences. In Proc. 1st International Conference on Knowledge Discovery and Data Mining (KDD’95), pp. 210-215, Montreal, Canada, August 1995.
Agrawal, Rakesh, and Ramakrishnan Srikant. “Fast algorithms for mining association rules.” Proc. 20th int. conf. very large data bases, VLDB. Vol. 1215. 1994.
Srikant, Ramakrishnan, and Rakesh Agrawal. “Mining sequential patterns: Generalizations and performance improvements.” International Conference on Extending Database Technology. Springer Berlin Heidelberg, 1996.
https://rapidminer.com/
Ioannou, A., and L. C. M. Itard. “Energy performance and comfort in residential buildings: Sensitivity for building parameters and occupancy.” Energy and Buildings 92 (2015): 216-233.
Dhar, Vasant. “Data science and prediction.” Communications of the ACM 56.12 (2013): 64-73.
http://www.opschaler.nl/
Kornaat, Wim, et al. “Development of improved models for the accurate pre-diction of energy consumption in dwellings.” (2016).
Majcen, D., L. C. M. Itard, and H. Visscher. “Theoretical vs. actual energy consumption of labelled dwellings in the Netherlands: Discrepancies and policy implications.” Energy policy 54 (2013): 125-136.
Dear, R. de, Gail Brager, and Donna Cooper. “Developing an adaptive model of thermal comfort and
preference-Final Report (ASHRAE RP-884).” Atlanta, GA: ASHRAE (1997).
Bouden, Chiheb, and Nadia Ghrab. “An adaptive thermal comfort model for the Tunisian context: a field study results.” Energy and Buildings 37.9 (2005): 952-963.
Heidari, Shahin, and Steve Sharples A comparative analysis of short-term andlong-term thermal comfort
surveys in Iran, Energy Build. 34.6 (2002)607–614.
Joseph Khedari, Boonlert Boonsri, Jongjit Hirunlabh, Ventilation impact of asolar chimney on indoor
temperature fluctuation and air change in a schoolbuilding, Energy Build. 32.1 (2000) 89–93.
https://www.cbs.nl/en-gb/news/2007/27/average-income-dutch-household-approximately-50-
thousand-euro
Santin, Olivia Guerra, Laure Itard, and Henk Visscher. “The effect of occupancy and building characteristics on energy use for space and water heating in Dutch residential stock.” Energy and buildings 41.11 (2009): 1223-1232.
Santin, Olivia Guerra. “Behavioral patterns and user profiles related to energy consumption for heating.” Energy and Buildings 43.10 (2011): 2662-2672.

CHAPTER 6
Van der Linden, A. C., et al. “Adaptive temperature limits: A new guideline in The Netherlands: A new approach for the assessment of building performance with respect to thermal indoor climate.” Energy and buildings 38.1 (2006): 8-17.
Peeters, Leen, et al. “Thermal comfort in residential buildings: Comfort values and scales for building energy simulation.” Applied Energy 86.5 (2009): 772-780.
Majcen D., Itard L., Visscher H. 2015, Statistical model of the heating prediction gap in Dutch dwell-ings:
Relative importance of building, household and behavioral characteristics, Energy and Buildings 105 (2015), 43-59.
Becker, R. and Paciuk, M., 2009. Thermal comfort in residential buildings–failure to predict by standard model. Building and Environment, 44(5), pp.948-960.
Khan, Muhammad Hammad, and William Pao. “Thermal Comfort Analysis of PMV Model Prediction in Air
Conditioned and Naturally Ventilated Buildings.”Energy Procedia 75 (2015): 1373-1379.
Beizaee, Arash, and Steven K. Firth. “A comparison of calculated and subjective thermal comfort sensation in home and office environment.” (2011).
De Dear, Richard. “Revisiting an old hypothesis of human thermal perception: alliesthesia.” Building Research & Information 39.2 (2011): 108-117.
http://sydney.edu.au/architecture/staff/homepage/richard_de_dear/ashrae_rp-884.shtml
Nicol, J. Fergus, and Michael A. Humphreys. “Adaptive thermal comfort and sustainable thermal standards for buildings.” Energy and buildings 34.6 (2002): 563-572.
Halawa, E., and J. Van Hoof. “The adaptive approach to thermal comfort: A critical overview.” Energy and
Buildings 51 (2012): 101-110.
How to Cite
IOANNOU, Anastasios. Thermal comfort and energy related occupancy behavior in Dutch residential dwellings. A+BE | Architecture and the Built Environment, [S.l.], n. 27, p. 244, oct. 2018. ISSN 2214-7233. Available at: <https://journals.library.tudelft.nl/index.php/abe/article/view/2773>. Date accessed: 22 feb. 2019. doi: https://doi.org/10.7480/abe.2018.27.
Published
2018-10-30